matters of scale

artThis image of life brought to you by Thoughtful Drivel.

Or something.  The story is this: an industrial development project gets caught out because of a submission made to the government regulatory agency which included a map that neglected to show a rather large river.  Said project will likely impact the river, the fishes in it, the folks that like chasing them fishes, etc, etc.  The official reason: a matter of scale, a quirk in the mapping data, an unintentional omission, quickly amended.

adThe story appears on the page of the newspaper and it looks like this.  Now on the same page, over and to the left, a paid ad depicts aerial photos of the nearby city, circa 1967 & today.  We see a shoreline then and now, a small coastal town on the rise.  Perhaps we feel impressed by this story of change and growth, this heritage moment.  The ad is brought to by… well, yep, the same developer.  It looks like this.

Okay, sympathy for the Devil time.  I don’t mean to insinuate some nefarious conspiracy here.  Yep, mapping geeks can make mistakes.  Even monumentally dumb ones.  And yes, their bosses also want to get a warm fuzzy glow to go with their logo, so they’ll sponsor some community feel-goods.  All part of the game.   But the irony of it all still smacks me, good and hard.

And it takes me back to this book.  It’s called How to Lie with Maps and it’s a classic little tome that found its way on to my thoughtful drivel radar during an otherwise tedious class back in the university days, all about the use of mapping software, or “GIS”.  The basic premise is that we have no choice but to lie.  Goes like this: smushing out flat the bumpy sphere of Earth obliges all kinds of distortions:

There are many others.  Distortion, fabrication, imperialist cartography, oh my!

But there’s another level to it.  As with photos, maps say something about the value we place on our experience of places.  It’s no surprise the details are strongest closest to home base.  The places and faces we hold most dear are those whose contours are etched most clearly in our maps and memories.  Beyond, the rest is vague and full of monsters and mystery, innit?  Terra incognita.  Or data insufficient, if you prefer.

But hey, it’s all fair game, right?  People can skew their depiction of reality to suit their values and interests, whatever.  Might as well have fun with it (try here or here).  If having values is lying, then so be it, we gotta lie.

This should be terra cognita for photographers.  Approach a subject as honestly as you think you can, it’s no good – your choice of the point of view, the light, what you crop in or leave out…  it’s all about manipulating the viewer into accepting your version of reality, right?  Or maybe your client’s.

Maybe, I dunno.  Back to the river, that question of scale.  It’s a big river and it looks pretty good in the right light.  Actually it’s pretty hard to miss.

now you see it

So the other day I’m watching these pink salmon hurl themselves upstream, and I’m thinking ‘they just don’t understand the scale of what they’re up against’, but that doesn’t stop them and somehow they’ll make it up that river.  More than once, this river has reminded me of the scale of things.

paddle winter 20120706-2012 untitled-771 slushIn the end I guess I’m not interested in telling lies with photos, or pretending to tell the Truth, whatever that would be.  I just want to tell a story that suggests what this place means to me.  And I’ll distort that if I need to.  There.  That’s my hidden agenda.

Ain't that sweet?

Ain’t that sweet?

 

Advertisements

3 comments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Fujifilm Blog

We love pictures, like you!

Capturing Music

4 out of 5 dentists recommend this WordPress.com site

Capturing Music

4 out of 5 dentists recommend this WordPress.com site

Photofocus

education and inspiration for visual storytellers

Morgan Rana Photography

Documentary and fine art wedding, lifestyle and travel photography

Thought Catalog

Thought Catalog is a digital youth culture magazine dedicated to your stories and ideas.

gregfallis.com

it's this or get a real job

hovercraftdoggy

A curated glimpse into a world of infinite beauty and creativity.

surface & surface

Art & Design Choice Cuts

Phil Kneen Photography

I shoot people...

Well Worn Soles

The Experiences and Opinions of Another Young White Male Backpacker

Claire Atkinson

maker of images

per Z pective

the state of my ideas

The Squeaky Robot

A Meddling Robot in a Human's World

The WordPress.com Blog

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

%d bloggers like this: